PDA

View Full Version : Rum and Price Point Discussion...


SarasotaRum
06-18-2008, 02:21 PM
As I learn, taste, and read more about Rum the following Generalizations have become apparent:

* The price paid for a bottle of rum does not always lead to a better tasting experience.
* Advanced aging does not always lead to a superior rum.
* A tasting occasion and tasting preference often overlooks a superior product on the basis of availability, affordability, or affinity. (this is a good thing)

I have often read posters state a particular preference for one brands 7 year over a 12. This curiousity naturally extends to purchasing decisions at the local liquor store and the myriad of strange new selections now available.

There are two many selections to count under the $20 mark. Most are distillied in the most economical way possible I'd imagine. The light shines through very easily. There are a few from central american countries which boast of cask aging and sipping which could be viable alternative for informal tasting if one was bold enough to give it a try. I did.

Ron Barcelo - Anejo / Dom. Rep. - light, but not harsh. Slight tinge characteristic of lower cost spirits, much better than cockspur 5, or flor de cana gold, suitable for shots straight between beers, probably keep your sniffers in the rack. $14

Ron Abuelo - Anejo / Panama - med., sweeter, some finish, definitely better for sipping. Small oak barrels, blended. Not quite premium league, but definitely in the ballpark. Some readers will a little less sophisticated palate will be pleased. $14 750l or $20 1.75l

My question for the forum is: do you know of any rum in this category that have seen the inside of a barrel that are worthy of a try ?

The $20- $29 range has the most gaps in it. This is where I would logically find most of my purchases, but it is where the liquor store has very little stock outside of the usual suspects. Robert's Rum Guide has many good canidates which might fit in this price range, I don't know. It was as if the store knew I was either going to purchase cheap rum or spend at least $35. quality 5 and 7 year rums are hard to find, but 15's and 21's are right there.

My question for the forum is: Do you have the same available problems with rum selections in the $20 range in your part of the country ?

The $30 and up range is well-round with Zacapa, De Cana, Viscaya, etc, etc, all in the fancy decanters with their prices clearly marked. These may be nice for the true armchair experience on the most special of occasions. The Flor De Cana 21 I tasted at Big Sugar last week was $72.

Final Thoughts: I guess what we are really talking about is a value proposition. If someone posts a positive review on a recent tasting, I think that only adds value. I look forward to reading your comments and sharing more in the future.

Sincerely,

Stan
SarasotaRum
Sarasota, Florida

Edward Hamilton
06-18-2008, 05:34 PM
There are a number of very good rums in the $20s. But there are also a number of rums which are commonly overlooked in the less than $20 price range. Mount Gay Sugar Cane Rum is commonly priced around or less than $20 and it shouldn't be overlooked.

Flor de Cana 4 year old white rum is priced at about the same as Bacardi and in my mind it should be priced above Bacardi's white rum. The larger bottles are an even better value.

And these are just two examples of nationally sold brands. In my experience, all too often import companies and marketers are looking to premiumize a product by charging more for it, with undesired results.

It is amazing to me that so-called premium vodkas sell at more than $25 and for that money I could stock a bar with rums that I'd be proud to serve my friends.

The short answer is that you'll have to learn about the different rums from experience or the experience of those you trust on this and other forums. There is no easy shortcut to experience. I've spent more than 15 years researching all the rums I could find and I'm introduced to new rums and new blendings of old rums every month.

The Scribe
06-18-2008, 06:05 PM
Another issue is location. Robert is located in Florida, where prices are around 10% less then they are in Massachusetts. Those in Florida, Illinois, California, and a few other states can get great selection at bargain prices. On the other hand, if you go up to New Hampshire, the prices are usually next to nothing, but the selection isn't so good. Meanwhile those of us in the rest of the northeastern United States, and even more so Canada and Europe have to pay much more. What might be a $20 rum in New Hampshire can be around $27 in Massachusetts, over $40 in Germany and a whopping $61 in England! (Note, however, that I converted all prices to American dollar equivalent. In nominal currency, it was between 27 and 30 in the last three cases.)

I know that wasn't necessarily very helpful, but I'll give you a few pretty decent rums that I can find for under $30 in Massachusetts:
- Angostura Rum 1919
- Rhum Barbancourt 5 Star (8 Years)
- Bacardi 8
- Bacardi Solera
- Cruzan Single Barrel
- El Dorado 12
- El Dorado 15 (Usually, occasionally it will be more.)
- Ron Pampero Aniversario

Hope this helps!
Cheers. - S

Berbician
06-19-2008, 11:51 PM
El Dorado 15 year old is £40 (US$78.40) in London.:mad::mad::mad:

Scottes
06-20-2008, 12:14 AM
Khukri is about $20, and a good sipper. Santa Teresa Gran Reserva cost me $17, and is a damn fine rum (though on the edge of being a sipper). And I have to agree about the Barbancourt 5-Star - that stuff blew me away, and then I found out how cheap it was.


Scribe, where are you finding the El Dorado 12? I recently visited Blanchard's in Jamaica Plain, and they're no longer carrying it. I love the 15, but the 12 is almost as good and much cheaper.

The Scribe
06-20-2008, 01:05 AM
Scottes -
I had seen it at Kappy's but I don't think I saw it last time I was there.
Cheers. - S

Lew Barrett
06-21-2008, 02:50 AM
Another under $30 rum of interest, especially to cigar smokers I think, is Centenario XX.

losty
03-22-2011, 07:10 PM
So i am base in UK(sux...)
For 50+ pound what would people suggest?
I already got ed 12, 15, zacapa23, fdc12, diplo green....
I am thinking of ed21 and zacapa xo, but do they justify their price??? (i actually sampled zacapa xo at rumfest but was too drunk to remember....)

SeldomSeen
03-23-2011, 07:14 AM
Zacapa XO is excellent IMHO. In my top 5. Not as sweet as Zacapa 23, but smoother and more complex. Try starting with it before you get drunk. party1.gif I can't speak to the Eldorado 21, but it also comes highly recommended and is next on my high end "must try" list. But I don't think you could go wrong with either. Do they justify their price?..... I guess that's subjective. But if it was a Scotch or another Whiskey with similar pedigrees, it'd be a lot more. They're worth a try once anyways.

gatomalo
03-23-2011, 07:33 AM
So i am base in UK(sux...)
For 50+ pound what would people suggest?
I already got ed 12, 15, zacapa23, fdc12, diplo green....
I am thinking of ed21 and zacapa xo, but do they justify their price??? (i actually sampled zacapa xo at rumfest but was too drunk to remember....)

You won't get Zacapa XO or El Dorado 21 for anything close to £50 (more like £75-90). Are they worth the price? Only you can answer that!

losty
03-23-2011, 06:55 PM
You won't get Zacapa XO or El Dorado 21 for anything close to £50 (more like £75-90). Are they worth the price? Only you can answer that!

I know.... thats why I had the "+" sign next to 50 lol
not many products can be found in the UK...